Critique - Value Scales
Critique - Value Scales
This lesson is premium only. Join us in the full course!
47:41
1.3K views
lesson video
Critique - Value Scales
courseDrawing BasicsFull course (177 lessons)
-20%
$127.20
$159
You save $31.8
comments 14 submissions
Alain Rivest
Hey thanks Stan for reviewing my value scale. Here is the sketch pad I used. And yes, it is a kneaded eraser. It's yellow, not green. Just very dirty! ;)
LESSON NOTES

In this lesson, we review common challenges in creating value scales and offer practical tips to improve your work. We address difficulties in distinguishing adjacent mid-tones and explain why it's important to use the full value range in your drawings. You'll learn how to establish your darkest dark and middle value to anchor your scale. We also discuss how paper texture and pencil choice affect shading, and the impact of lighting when drawing and photographing your artwork. This lesson aims to help you better perceive and render subtle differences in value.

Get this lesson and more in the premium course!

DOWNLOADS
mp4
critique-value-scales.mp4
2 GB
txt
critique-value-scales-transcript-english.txt
43 kB
txt
critique-value-scales-transcript-spanish.txt
45 kB
file
critique-value-scales-captions-english.srt
73 kB
file
critique-value-scales-captions-spanish.srt
80 kB
COMMENTS
Stan Prokopenko
Let’s take a look through your value scales! When you're working on your value scales, it's common to have trouble seeing the subtle differences in mid-tones. One big mistake I saw in a lot of your work was not going dark enough with your values. Make sure to stretch your range all the way to black and get comfortable using darker tones. Also, don’t jump too quickly from your darkest value to the next one. That compresses your mid-tones and makes it harder to see the steps clearly.
Newest
Chauncey Holder
This critique really helped me out i tired to stay away from the common mistake but i think i still ended up making it lol. but it was really helpful letting me see vaules abit better
kutolia
10mo
Thank you, Stan, for all the tips on types of pencils and paper, lights and taking photos! Love how each type of video (lessons, projects, demos and critique), each have lots of valuable information!
@romero505
11mo
Hello guys, could you give feedback on my practice??????? I love you guys xoxox
@leolopyz
10mo
for feedback on something like value scales pictures have to be taken with better lighting.. the upper left side of your pages is lit up while the bottom right is in shadow affecting all of your work on the page
zan
1yr
Thanks for the direct critique Stan! Totally see what you're saying about the jumps in value, though I'm still struggling a bit. Hard one!
@bert2
1yr
Does anyone how you would go about creating this short of line etching effect shading?
Melanie Scearce
Lots of layering directional lines. Try to copy this drawing and see what you figure out! Study the drawing, work in layers and start lightly. Notice how the artist follows the cross contours of the portrait.
Rachel Dawn Owens
Incredible value and edge control
Brandon
1yr
Thx for the advice Stan, The graphite one is definitely something that I am proud of, although the 0 and 1 could be done better. The airbrush one is not a trick or what, I just use it like a pencil, use the pure black (value 0) and use pressure to adjust the value, things got me confused is that it s hard to make the value consistent... Anyone have the experience on using that?
Vera Robson
Thank you Stan for addressing my question! It was super helpful to see the exact tools you used in Photoshop to clean up my photo. No more excuses for posting murky images 😉
Caroline
1yr
Thanks for the feedback, I have tried again and made the darkest value darker and the middle value darker, but I think the darker values (3 and 4) are now too similar. It's really hard!
@bert2
1yr
Is that value scale you showed in the beginning called denman ross value scale ? should i print that one out ? If not could you maybe share the one you showed ?
CharmLotta
1yr
Thanks for the detailed comment about the light. My desk lamp was good enough for all my hobbies so far, even for fairly precise work, like sewing or drawing with a fineliner. But distinguishing the subtle differences between the values in this assignment appeared difficult. I definitely have to test some different bulbs.
Juice
1yr
My problem was that my lightest tone was to dark. And the steps on my lighter Tones was to big. And my dark Tones was like one big dark value. I will do it again and use my new led i got. 2H. Before my lightest pen was HB. Had the same problem with my alkohol markers. Dont know how to make the lightest marker lighter. Maybe use a layer of uncolored alcohol first by using the blender. And use white colored pencil afterwards.
@bumatehewok
As a near sighted person, when I take of my glasses and squint it actually makes my vision more clear. So my two options are no glasses or squint with glasses on.
Alain Rivest
Hey thanks Stan for reviewing my value scale. Here is the sketch pad I used. And yes, it is a kneaded eraser. It's yellow, not green. Just very dirty! ;)
Juice
1yr
Just seconds after i was thinking ”what is that sketchbook?” Proko said the same 😄 cool never seen anything like it
Juice
1yr
I also need a Bowser figure to Hold my brush!
Juice
1yr
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!