Critique - Line Master Studies
Critique - Line Master Studies
This lesson is premium only. Join us in the full course!
35:24
6.2K views
lesson video
Critique - Line Master Studies
courseDrawing BasicsFull course (185 lessons)
-20%
$127.20
$159
You save $31.8
comments 118
K. J. Reittinger
Study of Christine Deschamps.
DOWNLOADS
mp4
critique-line-master-studies.mp4
1 GB
txt
critique-line-master-studies-transcript-english.txt
28 kB
txt
critique-line-master-studies-transcript-spanish.txt
29 kB
file
critique-line-master-studies-captions-english.srt
53 kB
file
critique-line-master-studies-captions-spanish.srt
54 kB
COMMENTS
Stan Prokopenko
It’s time for critiques! Let’s take a look through your master studies and see how much of their line work you were able to absorb.
Eric E
•
26d
Tried another master study! I'm thinking I could have done more dynamic differences with the line weight, but I might have to try an inking to get it more similar. Original by Hiro Mashima!
Ben K
•
25d
Yeah, I think you could go a touch thicker, especially on the outlines of the hair, but this looks really good! Nice job on the shading!
@janabouma
•
1mo
My study of a Norman Rockwell. Second attempt. Left the pipe off this time because it's bedtime. This was fun. Lots of practice making thick lines. (I see I missed a shadow under his left eye--on the right to the viewer.)
Fabio Bompani
Here are my line master studies. I chose Eliza Ivanova and David Malan. Eliza has incredible confidence in her linework—it looks like every line is in the right place on the first try. Malan also displays amazing confidence, and I love his zigzags and varied line weights. I tried—with limited success—to emulate their line quality, placing less emphasis on proportions and likeness, but it is truly difficult...
Charlotte
•
2mo
Here are my Line Master Studies - I chose Jeff Watts as I really admire the diversity and the complexity of his lines, and Glen Keane for the gestural, flowy nature of his drawings (which was so much harder to replicate than I thought haha). Any feedback would be appreciated! Also, I saw how Stan used a lot of the overhand grip in his Jeff demo which allowed him to pull such a wide range of lines, especially the softer ones. Has anyone got any advice on how to improve using this grip/holding the pencil this way? It sounds a bit obvious, but is it really just a case of just consistent practice with it? Thank you!
Marco Uggè
After watching the critique video, I tried a couple more master studies, focusing on the line of different artists.
kathryn martinez
Here is the assignment where I hope it was ok to use searching lines, because I certainly did use searching .lines...
kathryn martinez
This is about 3 years late, but finally getting serious about improving drawing. I have developed a very bad habit of measuring everything with calipers. This has negatively affected all drawing and painting . I truly didn't do it on this drawing. Feeling better already.
Larry
•
3mo
I attempted to draw this upside down and concentrate on the lines. learned a lot. It feels weird to leave gestural random searching lines; but I made myself leave them like the artist did. This was a handout from my Art Class at the the community Center
Larry
•
3mo
My drawing study is the one on the right
@kseniafeey
Alireza Heshmati
I think I have trouble with proportions.
Zeni
•
5mo
Frank Frazetta master study.. now that we were thought to observe a little bit more in depth, I am much more in awe of this particular master, and of course, of others as well! The drawing process is a whole freaking universe and I cannot wait to explore even more of it! Really grateful to Stan and the whole Proko team for these truly valuable lessons and dedication to help us grow! Thank you! p.s. sorry for not also posting the original artwork, I simply cannot find it anymore, it was from an instagram post from somewhere and forgot to save it!
Zeni
•
5mo
Found the original reference!
Howard Fullmer
I have been studying comic book characters from a drawing book is a master study ok from learning from books and working on Lines from the book. I have been drawing as many heads I can a day in the amount of time I have before going to work. I want to draw all the drawings from the book every day
Bislan Arakelian
1.Aaron Blaise 2.Bernie Wrightson 3.James Montgomery Flagg
@cozaman
•
7mo
Gave a go studying Glen Keane's work—I love his style. I'm actually pretty happy with how these came out. I love his gestural approach. Lots of practice with tapered lines, and first time I've really tried using the side of the pencil. The confidence borne from that study led me to give a Joe Madureira piece a go and that put me right back in my place haha. Definitely bit off more than I could chew there.
@ghostpengi
I had a go at this and got extremely sidetracked because of my study choice! I was able to be a bit more mindful of line weight, especially with how much importance is given to grouping outside vs inside features, and also saw how line weight would be occasionally changed to avoid monotony. I had fun with the exercise although admittedly my proportions were quite off which led to me redoing lines and them becoming pretty sloppy, I will try blocking in the larger masses next time so that I don't work too small, too quickly. The study on the left came from a Limbus Company image, and the one on the right came from one of the Jeff Watts skulls from earlier.
Ani
•
8mo
Another master copy of a Charles Dana Gibson - portrait of a gentleman with a basket. I used a sharp 2B for the thin lighter lines in the face and a blunt 4B and 6B for the clothing to vary weight and value.
Chuck Ludwig Reina
This looks amazing. You did a really good job of capturing the look in pencil. Really well done!
Ani
•
8mo
Here's my master copy of a Charles Dana Gibson ink brush drawing. I used charcoal and I had to adapt how I used it to create thin, thick, light, dark and tapered lines. Of all the exercises I have completed I have found this one the most valuable. Undeniably, this is a tough task. Having to problem solving your way to maintain some level of likeness but most importantly create marks that mimic the artist's requires some thinking. I kept a spare piece of paper on the side to practise my marks before putting them down. I've also included a photo of my favourite marks in the hair. I'll be spending a lot more time completing master copies I think. Great task!
Zetagé
•
11mo
I'm sharing my attempts. I'd gladly accept some feedback, as this is the first time I'm actually focusing on the linework. I'm a manga guy, so I tried two of my favorite artists: Haruhiko Mikimoto (Macross, Gunbuster) and Yoji Shinkawa (Metal Gear Solid), two very different styles with different challenges. I'm still searching for a good Master to learn from. So, I'm interested in visiting the artworks from Keitaro Miura (Berserk), Nobuhiro Watsuki (Rurouni Kenshin) and Rumiko Takahashi (Ranma 1/2) in the futuro, to check what I can find there. I admit it's been hard finding good lineart to learn from in manga, so I also accept suggestions. Thanks in advance.
Tanjiro Hisana
Here is a Master study I wanted to do of Kishimoto's character: Kushina Uzumaki. I found the way he confidently drew thin tapered strokes very tricky. Looking at his line weight, he gave most emphasis to her eyes while subtlety shifting his focus to the core facial features. So much erasing...
Panga Moise
•
11mo
After teacher's demo, I tried to draw art from Charles Dana Gibson and Glen Keane. Man, their lines are just perfect. I could replicate those curve lines with confidence.
Chuck Ludwig Reina
The Gibson Girl! Love it.
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!