Critique - Simplify to CSI
Critique - Simplify to CSI
This lesson is premium only. Join us in the full course!
52:15
14K views
lesson video
Critique - Simplify to CSI
courseDrawing BasicsFull course (185 lessons)
$159
comments 307
Mike See
I may have misunderstood the assignment:
LESSON NOTES

What's in Premium?

Drawing with Confident, Expressive Lines

This lesson teaches you how to replace "hairy lines" (multiple hesitant strokes) with confident, expressive lines that improve your drawings. You'll learn why this skill is crucial for drawing from imagination, animation, and even mechanical subjects.

The premium lesson covers:

  • Drawing with your whole arm - techniques for creating larger, more dynamic strokes with less fatigue
  • The ghosting method - a step-by-step approach to rehearsing lines before committing to paper
  • Understanding curve varieties - how to use C-curves, S-curves, and straight lines with intention rather than creating the "snowman effect"
  • Common mistakes including not simplifying enough, over-simplifying, and line quality issues
  • Form and structure considerations to balance flowing curves with structural straight lines

You'll gain practical techniques to immediately improve your line confidence, a fundamental skill that affects every aspect of your drawing practice.

Get the full lesson in the premium course.

DOWNLOADS
mp4
critique-simplify-to-csi.mp4
2 GB
txt
critique-simplify-to-csi-transcript-english.txt
49 kB
file
critique-simplify-to-csi-captions-english.srt
81 kB
txt
critique-simplify-to-csi-transcript-spanish.txt
50 kB
file
critique-simplify-to-csi-captions-spanish.srt
82 kB
COMMENTS
Stan Prokopenko
Let's take a look at your "Simplify to CSI" submissions! I decided to combine both level 1 & 2 students for this critique since I saw very similar mistakes at both levels.
Bill G
17d
First time I'm submitting an attempt... not sure that I was aiming for the intended goal, but here is what I've got!
Charlotte
22d
Here are my attempts at all four references before watching demos/critiques, any feedback would be greatly appreciated! Kinda regretted making the laces of the boots darker as soon as I did it, but they were too far gone at that point and I’d already spent so much time on them haha. The skeleton was my favourite one to do out of the four :)
Ben Kraske
17d
Excellent work all around! You've done a great job simplifying the lines, and they're so clean!
Anshika Roy
Here's my first attempt on the snail and boots.
Oya
20d
First attempt? This is so good
John Oz
24d
Need to work on consistent line pressure throughout and actually picturing the line I want to create instead of drawing a few and erasing the ones I don't want.
@vonun
27d
Hello everyone. I would love some critique on these. These are my exercises from the whole week. I watched the critique videos throught said week. When I arived at the last one it dawned on me. I drew all of the way too quick and didn't give my self enought time to think about the lines I wanted to make. I am also new to drawing digitaly. I learned a lot more about it but I had some starting difficulties where my pen made some weird marks. So the beginning ones may have some weird lines that are still visible. All of these are in chonological order and I posted the referece picture after my attempt. I would love to hear what I should be focusing on most during my practice and aspects I might have missed. Thanks in advance and have a great day^^
Nickdulis
28d
Too damn hot to work. Mild climate and melting with 40 degrees celsius. Was completely fed up trying to work. Still suck at proportions and made new brush that helped me improve my lines + is more like a pencil so I can practice line quality better.
Bashayerfhs Bash
Ok .
@esmarieb
1mo
After watching the demo and the critique I redid my snail. Here is my second attempt vs my first attempt (the one with too much detail).
Charlotte
22d
hi, i just wanted to say you can really see the improvement! :)
@kurodore
1mo
After critique notes I did this exercise on a water bottle.
Anthony
2mo
Final attempt after the video
@emilym
2mo
Did my level 1 drawing before watching the demo and critiques and absolutely realizing I didn’t do the assignment lol it was SO challenging to simplify and not try to draw the snail/boots “good”. I also found myself very lost in the details of the boots! Going to try some butterflies and moths with more obvious CSI lines and then try the boots again!
Bradley Gibson
I was kind of wondering what I do during this critiques other than just watching and listening to them. But I have found having these on in the background while also practicing using stock images and simplifying them has really helped
Lewis Lexter Yap
thanks for sharing this practice
Wong Colleen
The second version...
@xolotl1973
Don't think I simplified enough in the assignment, so tried a few more.
@ralk
4mo
Not so much an improvement in technique as changing my mindset. Stan recommended going back to give the boots another go if the laces were hard, and I think it is indeed a valid exercise in diligent shape-matching, thoroughly working from one side of the laces to the other, and trying to resolve each potential curve. I don't think I can fully let go of chicken-scratching my lines from years of careless doodling, especially with the laces' rapid curvature changes and small size, but I stuck to simple, sweeping lines when I see the opportunity to process and simplify. Doing the laces felt frustrating at first, but finding the fun in it kept me going.
Abby
4mo
Oh man. I haven't had it in me to try a second attempt at the boots (yet?). I really love how thin and flat you've drawn the bottom of the boots. Especially your 1st version, they feel really grounded and have a ton of character. I agree laces are much cleaner/better done in the second for sure. But I have to say, I think using more curved/fewer straight lines for the boot bodies in the 2nd version really loses that character and grounding of the 1st. Just an observation! I'm sure you were mostly focusing on the laces in the 2nd but it's interesting to see what Stan mentioned playing out here - that the combination of straight and curved lines in your 1st drawing works really well. Anyway, great job!
Elizabeth Steele
Some more CSI sketches! Tell me what you guys think!
Kevin Gasanli
Great sketches, they look pretty good overall. I think the wolf one is the weakest one of the three, since it has a lot of lines that kind off fade off which makes some shapes like the ears feel incomplete. But overall I think these are pretty nice, they look loose and the lines look fluid and confident which is the most important thing for CSI sketches.
Ani
5mo
I enjoyed this task. Though I did get a little bogged down with accuracy and proportions. I can see some students were able to complete the boots in a short time. This just wasn't happening for me. Though by the time I reached Skelly, I was definitely more confident with making CSI marks. All tips and tidbits welcome!
Nero
5mo
Very fun exercise
@gurkan
6mo
Hey, Being patient and dedicated seems to be key, and most importantly, I'm having a lot of fun drawing these things, but I know that a lot of practice is needed to make progress.
Tomas M
7mo
CSI boots assignment
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!