Suggestion: addition of Discord server
1yr
Green Ethics
I personally have found the Discord community platform to be most functional for this application. Real time voice/video/sharing. REAL TIME! Voice! Video! Sharing! Great for the community in general but many uses become apparent such as classes and workshops... all under one platform!(PS Art-wod has successfully implemented its usage.) Thanks.
Reply
Drop images here to attach them to the message
All posts
Newest
Carlos Navarrete
As someone who's not a professional, who's more of a hobbyst, most of the times I've started and stopped drawing it was because of a lack of sense of community. Having people to just chat about lessons as if it were a real classroom in real time is lacking in many platforms. I sorely miss something like that. Definitely in favor of something like this.
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
Charline B.R.
No, I disagree. Discord is great for small group that want to study together, not for full community. In the end it's a mess and push solo-centric behavior instead. Plus no archiving possible... Proko roadmap already plan to add a chat inside the website, in my opinion this would be more than enough. If people want to make rooms to talk to/see each other outside of proko, more power to them, at least they can group in smaller numbers that are workable. Also, Proko forum has its set of rules and Discord has its own, which can change on a wim. One of them being no nude rules if the server is public. For an art platform it is going to be a problem sooner than later. We can also have a serious headache with copyright material posted in Discord :) Better not add complexity where it's not needed, right ?
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
Andre Chris-Sargent
I agree. However, there are pros and cons to it, and examples of it working really excellently. Pros: Real Time Feedback, a constant sense of community, voice and video sharing, chances for people to announce that they're streaming. Cons, and really this is the big one: It's going to pull foot traffic away from the website. If there's just a better, more accessible platform than proko, why would people visit proko? There's a solution for this, however: keep the lessons on here. Announce when a new lesson is going up in a #announcements channel. It's also going to take a whole lot of manpower and server expertise. I don't know if Stan has the know-how to do that, and paying people to do it takes money; it would need to be a tightly moderated community, since Proko is a brand now as opposed to just a content creator. Examples: Ethan Becker and Sinix both have thriving discord communities. They've built up places for people to grow, learn, and share experiences. Overall, I think the suggestion for a discord is a phenomenal one, and I'm fully in support of it, but I wonder about the efficacy of actually getting it off the ground.
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
Green Ethics
I really think this site is missing out on this great opportunity. I want the best for Stan, the site and all his team. I hope they will take notice: at least 2 of your colleagues in this art video tutorial business use Discord with success. Force drawing has just added it. I cannot fathom any reason why not to ADD its functionality to this site to create the community atmosphere you desire with Proko 2.0. The BBS or blog or forum model being used here is not adequate in this day and age of real-time, streaming, audio/video simplicity. Thank you.
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
Carlos Navarrete
I remember when I was taking The Art Department classes. We had a real time chat app that we used, many friendships were born through it and people pushed each other to keep working. It was a great atmosphere. I think we used slack, but discord is just as good, if not better for a study environment
Reply
Dan B
I'll provide the counter-opinion that I'd prefer the community remain as much as possible within this platform. It feels like Stan and the team have put a lot of effort into this site and I see the huge benefit of them being able to customise it and prioritise features that most meet community needs, rather than taking what you get through Discord.
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
Shelvs Fleurima
Agreed, this place is nice. But discord would be great, at least give me a discord news to follow and get notifications on mobile
Reply
Green Ethics
it seems you are unaware of what Discord is. It would allow the 'addition' of many fantastic features that promote sharing and community.
Reply