Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite Matt instead of Charcoal/Conte/Wolff Pencils?
7mo
@haziz
I am working both here as well as on a Watts Atelier online drawing subscription. The atelier seems to recommend a mix of Conte, Wolff Carbon and General’s charcoal pencils. My understanding is that the Conte 1710 and Wolff’s Carbon are essentially proprietary graphite/charcoal blends.
I also have Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite Pencils and Staedtler Mars Lumograph Black pencils which are also graphite/carbon blends. I am partial to the Faber-Castill Pitt Graphite Pencils and would like to use them instead of the Conte or Wolff pencils. They feel much smoother to me, and I can also usually get away quite easily with sharpening them in a good quality manual sharpener (KUM “Automatic Long Point” dual slot sharpener) which I do prefer over the Xacto knife/sandpaper block method. They are not as dark as the Wolff and Conte pencils but still seem to me to be plenty dark. There is a very slight hint of the graphite sheen to the laid-down markings but it still does not look obtrusive to me. I am also OK with the Staedtler Mars Lumograph Black pencils but generally prefer the feel of the Faber-Castells.
Anybody using these pencils for their assignments? If yes, have you gotten a slap on the wrist from the instructors for deviating from the instructions? What is your experience using them.
I will probably go ahead and submit my next couple of assignments this way and see. I am also tinkering with the Wolff’s and Conte(s) in the meantime (the Conte(s) 1710 are simply awful). The Wolff pencils are fairly usable but I still strongly prefer the Faber-Castells.
Any input or feedback appreciated.
To make sure everyboy understands what I am talking about these are the pencils I am referring to:
https://www.fabercastell.com/products/pitt-graphite-matte-pencil?srsltid=AfmBOooBbvr40xVf8TIhlmlv4NXByMy6y8Ljbb4FSOT4b3kAjnfbKn_X
•
7mo
Can't speak for Watts Atelier but here I would advise that you work with whatever material you want to learn with! Keeping in mind the characteristics of the material...there's certain things that graphite can't do that charcoal can and vice versa. A huge upside of self-directed learning is that you can practice in the ways that are inline with your goals.
I am no teacher, but I love combining the Faber-Castell matt graphite pencils (14B) with charcoal. You can basically make pencil drawings with lines that are almost as black as charcoal, without the reflectivity of normal pencil drawings.
The mars lumograph black 8b pencil is also quite black, but less smooth and less controllable.
And adding Conté pencil (Pierre Noire 2B) on top of a charcoal + graphite matt pencil, still adds another layer of depth.