@wetumbrella6
@wetumbrella6
Earth
Steve Lenze
I like the idea of this cover, I always liked pulp covers (I also like tango!) I noticed some things that had to do with drawing and placement that I thought would help your image without changing it much. I did a quick diagram and mock up to show you how you could fix some of these things. I hope you find it helpful :)
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@wetumbrella6
Hey Steve, Thank you so much for the detailed and helpful feedback, I really appreciate the time and effort you took for it. Now, based on your advice, I'm have started a new cover for my story. This one is more realistic and has changes based on the suggestions from you and my other friends. I'll post the WIP line art on the forums soon. Thanks again!
Reply
@wetumbrella6
Hi everyone, So I need feedback on my pulp poster. It's for my own novel set in the 1940s, and involves some of my characters. I would be glad to know any of your opinions. Thanks in advance!
Liandro
Hey, @wetumbrella6, welcome to the Proko community! I agree with @Steve Lenze, nice job working on this drawing! I can tell you’ve put some time and care into it. Hope you’ve found the process enjoyable and enriching! I stand by Steve’s recommendations. And since his feedback already covers the most relevant stuff regarding the construction and the composition, I’ll just add a complement specifically regarding the line work. In the drawings you posted, it's noticeable that all the lines have basically the same thickness and value. My suggestion would be that you try to look for ways to create more overall line variety. Some of the possible solutions could be: -- Making the lines on the foreground thicker and “heavier” than the lines on the background (which is something Steve had already suggested and that should help shift not only the sense of depth, as he properly noted, but also the composition and visual appeal of the drawing); -- Creating some thick-to-thin transitions (kind of emulating the feel of an inking brush); -- Making the lines on the background not only thinner, but also lighter (maybe make them gray instead of black). This could exaggerate even more the sense of depth and also create an even clearer read for the separation between foreground and background; -- Using a line weight criteria, such as "light and shadow" or "hierarchy of importance", to decide how to design your lines when inking. Stan talks about this topic in his lesson on How to Draw with Line Weight, which is part of the Drawing Basics course. As a visual feedback for the comments above, I’m attaching a quick "before-and-after" draw-over I made based on a portion of your original drawing. Please keep in mind that my draw-over is not necessarily "the right way", but merely an illustration of a few of the possibilities you could choose to stick with. Of course, any creative/artistic decision you might make should depend on your personal preferences. One more thing! I think it’s pretty cool that you were able to draw this scene without any reference, and if being able to draw without reference is part of a current goal or challenge you may have set for yourself, then it’s great that you’ve dared to attempt it and succeeded. With that said, I’d also highly encourage you to definitely use reference whenever you notice the need! In the case of this artwork, if you allow me the suggestion, I personally believe that some reference could be especially helpful for you to give a little extra touch of development to the environment, textures and props (bricks, wood, lamp, clock…), as well as to the characters' facial expressions - it could help you capture nuances and subtleties on the lips, brows and eyes that are often harder for us to envision just from memory. Hope you find this helpful. Other than that, just keep up the good work!
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@wetumbrella6
Hi Liandro, Thank you so much for the feedback. I agree with you regarding the line weight and thickness. I will try to work more on this element. Based on your suggestion, I have made the background a bit thinner while changing the background lines color to a lighter shade of grey. Here's the result so far (I have changed the guy's face, btw) Thanks again for the guidance!
Reply
Steve Lenze
Hey wetumbrella6, I really like the mood and feeling of this drawing, nice job. I do have some things that I think will help you going forward. First of all, you must work out your perspective and background so that your figures make sense with them. Then make sure your figures are placed properly and that they are the right proportions and anatomy. Your background doesn't make much sense and is very flat. Also, I think that is a fireplace in the upper right, but it is too small and too high for the perspective that you do have. When it comes to inking this, you must make the lines in the background thinner than those in the foreground or they will look like they are on the same plan. I did a quick sketch to show you the steps you should use to come to your finished piece, I hope it helps :)
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@wetumbrella6
Thanks so much Steve, I really appreciate your critique. The couple are meant to be sitting on a bed, not a couch. That's why they're wearing pajamas. But still I appreciate the rest of your helpful feedback and will try to use your advice in my art. Btw, I decided to change the guy's face and hair, here’s the new one:
Reply
@wetumbrella6
Hi everyone, first time poster here. So I started to draw comic style line arts to illustrate my own novel. The attached image is my first attempt at line art illustration based on the story. I have experience doing character designs, but never tried something like this before. Let me know if you have any feedback or opinions, or improvement suggestions for my next drawings. Note that while I usually have references, for this drawing I didn't use any reference. Thanks in advance!
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!
Your name
Email
Message