@c_moon
@c_moon
Earth
A beginner artist with a dream of becoming a manga artist or concept artist
@c_moon
2yr
I finally tried to do a master study of a famous painting and it looks pretty crappy but it's a first I guess, I only used one layer here and tried not to erase and color pick as much as possible. It looks very inaccurate. I also tried to do some kind of painterly style but it doesn't look like it. What do you guys think of this and what should I keep in mind when doing these kinds of studies?
Steve Lenze
Hey c_moon, first off, congrats on your first illustration, that a big achievement. I think the pose is good, but has some issues with proportion. I always do a structural drawing first to work out my proportions and perspective. That way I don't do a lot of work on my drawing if the proportions are wrong. Your instincts are good by having her in front of the cave opening. It's called a framing device, and is used to help guide the viewer to the main subject. I think though if your going to use it, you should make the opening larger so that she is framed by it better. I also think your use of a limited palette of colors is also good, especially for your first illustration. It gives the piece a cohesion. The only thing that I would do with the color is have the outside of the cave be a cool color for a nice contrast. over all, you did a nice job. I hope my sketch is helpful :)
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@c_moon
Thanks for taking the time to critique, again I appreciate it. I didn't know about the framing device, interesting. That's actually what I started on with the figure but yours looks much cleaner. I'm still not sure about how to approach wrinkles and clothing, I find it really difficult and whenever I try to apply it, it just feels a bit random. I don't know how to study or how to look for references on it. What's your suggestions? By the way the background's not a cave, it's actually a forest. Which explain the leaves on top if you were wondering, I feel like I could have done better to show the BG is a forest although I don't know what to do exactly.
Reply
@c_moon
After a few days, I've finally finished my first illustration! I'm not sure what specific critique I should ask here because there's a lot of stuff to go from here so I guess I'm going with asking for general critique instead. What issues does this painting have and what stuff should I improve on? Also the pose I drew is from imagination so I'm curious what you guys think of it. I'm just a beginner right now so some honest constructive critique is appreciated here.
@c_moon
First time studying this subject, some critique is appreciated. I used the eyedropper tool here a lot and I was wondering if that's "cheating" or not, I'm still a beginner and trying to get into digital art.
@yaboiethan
I think for the drawing in the middle, the pose is a bit off-balance as the center of mass isn't above the straightened leg. Also, the head is a bit big. Overall, I think you got the gesture down pretty well but it would be better if you really showed which parts are being stretched and which are compressed by using more decisive curves, for example, the left side of the third drawing could've just been drawn with one c curve. Another example is on the right side of the hips on the first drawing, you drew an awkward bump that goes against the gesture. Also for gesture studies, don't focus on the details and shading and try to do them as quickly as possible. Don't rush learning anatomy yet and make sure you can draw accurate proportions first. I hope this helped!
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@c_moon
How do you study proportion? I never really found any way to practice it other than knowing how many heads each major part has.
Reply
@c_moon
First time doing this sort of thing, all the figures I've done up until this point were gestures and mannequins so I want to hear what you guys think. I still don't know much about anatomy (haven't read that one Bridgman book yet because idk how to start) other than the basic shapes and maybe a few muscles and bones.
@paper
Hello @c_moon,honestly most of these heads looks pretty good,you said you had struggle for no4,7,9 but I only see problem with the perspective on no 4 and 9.On 4 specifically I think you're underuestamiting how much skull is shaped like an oval from atop and as for no 9 I think you should made the hole of the nose a bit more squashed since we're looking from below (also here's some overpainting if that helps) On the topic of wanting to draw stylized anime head,I recommend (if you haven't seen it) watching this video by Ethan Becker (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVwCDv5_ahg) where he recommend to simplify the face and learning to draw expression on the face and learning how other anime-esque artist you like simplifying the face (he also has some good tip about drawing faces too) BUt anyway,good job,really love how you're posting consistently!(This is how you get good quick)Keep going,you're doing great!
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@c_moon
Hey thanks man, I really appreciate the help you've been doing recently. I actually watched a bit of Ethan Becker before and been liking his videos so thanks for the recommendation! I think I may have to practice more skulls in extreme angles and even tilts, something I've been struggling with for a long time.
Reply
@nolria
Hi, i highly recomend a book tittled "Constructive Anatomy" by George B. Bridgman, the explanations are a little bit tough to understand but the examples in this book really helped me to understand anatomy in a more dynamic way, for your drawings, I personally think it's better if you start your skeleton with 2 boxes and a line that represents the spine and simple lines to indicate the arms and legs, after it you can draw over these boxes and start making the shapes of the body.
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@c_moon
So I just skimmed through the book and most of the pages seems to be mostly illustrations. How did you approach this book? Also are you talking about the Robo-Bean or something similar to it? Maybe an example would help if you don't mind.
Reply
@c_moon
added a new topic
Skull Studies
2yr
I've recently started doing skull studies since I heard it'll help me get better with head/face drawing, this is my first study. I have difficulty drawing heads/skulls in extreme angles (Skull #4, #7, and #9). What other stuff should I also do to improve my head drawing? My goal is to be able to draw stylized heads, something like in an anime art style.
@c_moon
Finally got to doing this, it wasn't easy. I had a hard time drawing these especially the 5 min. figures. I felt like my figures got a bit stiff and disproportionate. Also do I need to draw the Robo-Bean first before turning the figure into a mannequin? Because I feel like its making process much harder. I'm struggling and I need some tips and critique. As always, it's greatly appreciated.
@paper
Hello @c_moon nice to see you again,these are pretty good!I think the biggest problem I see,is what Dorian Iten call dirty light,where you make the half tone too dark.and also the little reflective light on the bottom is a bit too bright.(here's an overpainting if that helps) But anyway,not much problem other than that,please continue and post your progress here :D
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@c_moon
I'll keep in mind to post more if I can, thanks!
Reply
@c_moon
I've been trying to get into digital art as of recently and followed a long tutorial for Krita and digital art basics to help start out (3 hours long, I'm still not done with it). This is my first attempt doing this kind of stuff and I want to hear your thoughts. Sphere on the left is the first one I did, the one on the right is a copy of the first one but with an attempt to add some texture to it.
Steve Lenze
Hey c_moon, your drawings have pretty good gesture to them, so try to keep that going forward. I took a couple of your drawings and did a sketch over them to show you what you should be thinking of while doing these. One of the most important things is to make sure the torso and pelvis relate to each other properly. The distance between them, how they tilt in relation to each other and so forth. Also, all your figures are too short, so think about proportion as well. I hope this helps :)
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@c_moon
Thanks for the critique. I have a question but how do you practice proportion? I've always struggled getting this part right.
Reply
@c_moon
I've been drawing a lot of robo-beans and decided to challenge myself by drawing a couple poses from imagination. It was bit of a fun exercise (although thinking of a pose took some time) and I even did a few poses from extreme angles. What do you guys think of this and what can I improve on? A big goal of mine is moving on to mannequinization but I feel like I have to draw more robo-beans before I'm ready.
@paper
Oh hey it's you Hey,you fix the leg!Your proportion is definetly more consistent now.You captured most of the gesture pretty well and you made the "boxes" facing the right way.Though I think some of these could be improve a little,particulary the bottom on no 3,the right leg I feel could be twisted a little bit more and I think you could improve the pose if your turn the head to the right ( here's an overpainting if that helps) But other than that not much else (atleast from my observation)Anyway,pretty good.Please keep going,you're doing great :D
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@c_moon
Hey thanks again for the critique, it's very helpful.
Reply
@c_moon
added a new topic
First Robo-Beans
2yr
I finally got into doing the Robo-Beans for the first time after remembering it after a week, the gesture drawings don't have any time limit as I didn't know how much time I'd spent drawing the Bean along with building the Robo-Bean from it in each pose. Critique is as always, greatly appreciated.
@paper
Hello C_moon,welcome to the community,I hope you have a great time here!Yes I think you should move on to the robo bean,partly because I think you're getting the hang of gesture and weight and should probably get used to structure and proportion. I don't have much to say to the drawings except that it feels like in some of these I think you made the leg too short.Like for example on the first page the two drawings on the right and the one in the middle seemed to have it's leg scrunch up.I also see some of this in the third page on the two on the right and the middle.I suggest keeping an eye on this the next time you do a figure drawing and try to correct it .(Here are some overpainting if that helps) But other than that you're doing good,Please keep improving! (Also nice yukari profile pic)
Write reply...
Drop images here to attach them to the message
@c_moon
Thank you very much for critique! I felt like something was wrong with some of those legs so I really appreciate you pointing that out and I'll keep in mind what you suggested.
Reply
@c_moon
Hello, I'm new here (beginner artist) and recently watched Proko's video on The Bean and tried applying it on my gesture drawings, I'm still not sure if I'm doing gestures right or if I should move on to the Robo-Bean so critique is greatly appreciated.
Help!
Browse the FAQs or our more detailed Documentation. If you still need help or to contact us for any reason, drop us a line and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!
Your name
Email
Message